clock menu more-arrow no yes
Yolan at the Joseph, a Luxury Collection Hotel, Nashville

Where to Eat Italian Food in Nashville

All of the carbonara and risotto fit for print

View as Map

They say that the way to a person’s heart is through the stomach. Italians know this. That’s why no one can seem to get enough of their heart-warming, soul-fulfilling plates of pasta goodness — keto diet and all. In fact, it’s safe to say that Italians have the market covered when it comes to the universally beloved comfort food.

Luckily, Nashville has several savory Italian standbys ready to fill that lasagna or carbonara craving. Here are 13 local options that showcase some of the best that Nashville’s Italian restaurants have to offer, from Neapolitan pies to decadent plates of seafood-studded linguini.

New to the list in this update: Tony Mantuano’s new-to-Nashville Italian standout Yolan and more casual, counter-service PennePazze.

Pomodoro East leaves the list, as it remains temporarily closed due to a fire.

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.

1. City House

Copy Link
1222 4th Ave N
Nashville, TN 37208
(615) 736-5838
Visit Website

A staple since opening nearly 15 years ago, Nashville native Tandy Wilson’s Southern riff on rustic Italian fare made him the first Nashville chef to take home a James Beard Award. The belly ham pizza, Sunday supper’s meatball special, and talented pastry chef Rebekah Turshen’s desserts are all crucial when dining at City House.

City House/Facebook

2. Nicky's Coal Fired

Copy Link
5026 Centennial Blvd
Nashville, TN 37209
(615) 678-4289
Visit Website

Nicky’s is a hands-on affair — all the charcuterie, pasta, bitters, infusions, and shrubs are made in-house here. They’ve even got an herb garden that helps add some extra oomph to their dishes. Not that it’s needed — while the coal-fired pizza is definitely a thing, dishes like corn and scallop spaghetti, three cheese ravioli, and cavatelli bolognese are absolute showstoppers. Be sure to wind up the meal with one of Nicky’s house-spun gelatos or sorbets.

On the current menu: spaghetti, bay scallops, roasted corn, corn cream, lemon, basil, Grana Padano
Nicky’s Coal Fired/Facebook

3. Trattoria Il Mulino

Copy Link
144 5th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37203
(615) 620-3700
Visit Website

The Nashville outpost of this upscale New York-based Italian restaurant lives up to its reputation with both flawless service and exquisitely presented dishes. Start with the calamari picante, then move onto one of the pasta dishes, like the goat cheese ravioli or fettuccini with Parmesan cream sauce. The filet is another standout for those avoiding pasta. Finish with the warm brioche budino with grappa-soaked raisins — just think of it as a digestif.

4. Yolan

Copy Link
403 4th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37201
(615) 231-0405
Visit Website

Nashville scored big when this husband-and-wife culinary powerhouse moved to town (and when it got a see-thru cheese cave). James Beard Award-winning chef Tony Mantuano and wine/hospitality expert Cathy Mantuano brought Nashville the fine dining Italian menu it had been missing alongside standout service and a welcoming atmosphere inside the new Joseph Hotel. The chef’s tasting menu (plus expert wine pairings) is always a solid move, as are any and all of the pasta options. And save some room for pastry chef Noelle Marchetti’s jaw-dropping desserts.

Haas & Haas Photography | Yolan

5. Moto

Copy Link
1120 McGavock St
Nashville, TN 37203
(615) 736-5305
Visit Website

Ask any local about their top three favorite Italian joints around town, and this Gulch date night contender consistently sweeps the list. And it’s no surprise — one look at the sleek midcentury modern decor, discreet wraparound booths, and warm candlelit glow practically clinches its spot on those lists. But the black spaghetti with lobster ragu and Heritage pork chop (with FatBack bacon) on the menu are proof that Moto has just as much substance as it has style.

Moto/Facebook

6. Valentino's Ristorante

Copy Link
1808 Hayes St
Nashville, TN 37203
(615) 327-0148
Visit Website

Though they relocated from West End to Hayes Street, this Midtown staple has been serving up Italian classics to hungry locals for over 25 years. Think homemade lasagne with wild boar bolognese, bucatini, and cioppino. Need the narrow down the list? Valentino’s also offers a prix fixe menu with four courses for $55, as well as an upgraded version for $65.

7. PennePazze

Copy Link
3826 Charlotte Ave
Nashville, TN 37209
(615) 730-3088
Visit Website

This more casual, counter-service pizza and pasta spot sits on the street-facing side of the new L&L Market. On the menu, find plenty of pinsa (pizza) options plus signature pastas and salads

all available for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.

PennePazze/Facebook

8. Coco's Italian Market

Copy Link
411 51st Ave N
Nashville, TN 37209
(615) 783-0114
Visit Website

Visitors can load up on fresh burrata, heaps of fettuccine with meatballs, and deep-dish timpano at this restaurant/market hybrid. Post-carb-feast served either indoors or on the covered patio, diners can enjoy a glass of wine or beer while perusing the Italian market.

9. Pastaria

Copy Link
8 City Blvd
Nashville, TN 37209
(615) 915-1866
Visit Website

The brainchild of chef Gerard Craft, Pastaria serves up some seriously craveable carbs from its bright and airy outpost in the OneC1ty complex. Watch as dishes like cacio e pepe, garganelli, and pistachio ravioli pile out fresh from the open kitchen. The grab-and-go gelato counter by the door is a nice touch, for a post-pasta sweet treat.

Spencer Pernikoff/Pastaria Nashville

10. Giovanni Ristorante

Copy Link
909 20th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37212
(615) 760-5932
Visit Website

After 27 years in Manhattan, Giovanni Ristorante found its way to Nashville and firmly planted its flag near Midtown with a snappy bi-level space, and soon followed it up with a counterpart in Belle Meade. Murano glass chandeliers, Venetian plaster, and a Hermes (yes, that Hermes) upholstered bar provide some visual eye candy while plates like pappardelle alla Norcia with black truffles and tagliatelle with veal tempt the taste buds.

11. Bella Napoli Pizzeria | Pizza Nashville

Copy Link
1200 Villa Pl #206
Nashville, TN 37212
(615) 891-1387
Visit Website

While Bella Napoli is known for its perfectly blistered pies using ingredients imported directly from Italy, the rest of the menu is worth its weight in pasta gold. Especially when it comes to dishes like rigatoni salsiccia and the pork saltimbocca with Parma prosciutto and fontina cheese. During happy hour, glasses of the house red or white go for $5; well drinks are only $4.

12. Caffé Nonna

Copy Link
4427 Murphy Rd
Nashville, TN 37209
(615) 463-0133
Visit Website

Chef Daniel Maggipinto has been charming guests at this Sylvan Park eatery with his grandmother’s (the titular Nonna) traditional recipes for years. Starters like arancini and a hearty Tuscan bean soup segue smoothly into mains like mussels served fra diavolo or apulia-style with a saffron-tomato broth. There’s also a build-your-own pasta plate option featuring rigatoni, gnocchi, and risotto with an abundance of sauces, meats, veggies, and cheeses for topping.

13. Mangia Nashville

Copy Link
701 Craighead St
Berry Hill, TN 37204
(615) 750-5233
Visit Website

While it’s nice to stop by on a weeknight for a beautifully plated pasta dish by executive chef Nick Pellegrino, Fridays and Saturdays get pretty lit at this Berry Hill Italian spot. One seating is offered from 7 to 10 p.m. and features a family-style meal of various antipasti, pasta dishes, vegetables, and mains like chicken piccata or shrimp scarpiello. Copious glasses of wine turn the atmosphere up a touch and give guests the liquid courage to get up and bust some moves.

1. City House

1222 4th Ave N, Nashville, TN 37208
City House/Facebook

A staple since opening nearly 15 years ago, Nashville native Tandy Wilson’s Southern riff on rustic Italian fare made him the first Nashville chef to take home a James Beard Award. The belly ham pizza, Sunday supper’s meatball special, and talented pastry chef Rebekah Turshen’s desserts are all crucial when dining at City House.

1222 4th Ave N
Nashville, TN 37208

2. Nicky's Coal Fired

5026 Centennial Blvd, Nashville, TN 37209
On the current menu: spaghetti, bay scallops, roasted corn, corn cream, lemon, basil, Grana Padano
Nicky’s Coal Fired/Facebook

Nicky’s is a hands-on affair — all the charcuterie, pasta, bitters, infusions, and shrubs are made in-house here. They’ve even got an herb garden that helps add some extra oomph to their dishes. Not that it’s needed — while the coal-fired pizza is definitely a thing, dishes like corn and scallop spaghetti, three cheese ravioli, and cavatelli bolognese are absolute showstoppers. Be sure to wind up the meal with one of Nicky’s house-spun gelatos or sorbets.

5026 Centennial Blvd
Nashville, TN 37209

3. Trattoria Il Mulino

144 5th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37203

The Nashville outpost of this upscale New York-based Italian restaurant lives up to its reputation with both flawless service and exquisitely presented dishes. Start with the calamari picante, then move onto one of the pasta dishes, like the goat cheese ravioli or fettuccini with Parmesan cream sauce. The filet is another standout for those avoiding pasta. Finish with the warm brioche budino with grappa-soaked raisins — just think of it as a digestif.

144 5th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37203

4. Yolan

403 4th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37201
Haas & Haas Photography | Yolan

Nashville scored big when this husband-and-wife culinary powerhouse moved to town (and when it got a see-thru cheese cave). James Beard Award-winning chef Tony Mantuano and wine/hospitality expert Cathy Mantuano brought Nashville the fine dining Italian menu it had been missing alongside standout service and a welcoming atmosphere inside the new Joseph Hotel. The chef’s tasting menu (plus expert wine pairings) is always a solid move, as are any and all of the pasta options. And save some room for pastry chef Noelle Marchetti’s jaw-dropping desserts.

403 4th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37201

5. Moto

1120 McGavock St, Nashville, TN 37203
Moto/Facebook

Ask any local about their top three favorite Italian joints around town, and this Gulch date night contender consistently sweeps the list. And it’s no surprise — one look at the sleek midcentury modern decor, discreet wraparound booths, and warm candlelit glow practically clinches its spot on those lists. But the black spaghetti with lobster ragu and Heritage pork chop (with FatBack bacon) on the menu are proof that Moto has just as much substance as it has style.

1120 McGavock St
Nashville, TN 37203

6. Valentino's Ristorante

1808 Hayes St, Nashville, TN 37203

Though they relocated from West End to Hayes Street, this Midtown staple has been serving up Italian classics to hungry locals for over 25 years. Think homemade lasagne with wild boar bolognese, bucatini, and cioppino. Need the narrow down the list? Valentino’s also offers a prix fixe menu with four courses for $55, as well as an upgraded version for $65.

1808 Hayes St
Nashville, TN 37203

7. PennePazze

3826 Charlotte Ave, Nashville, TN 37209
PennePazze/Facebook

This more casual, counter-service pizza and pasta spot sits on the street-facing side of the new L&L Market. On the menu, find plenty of pinsa (pizza) options plus signature pastas and salads

all available for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.

3826 Charlotte Ave
Nashville, TN 37209

8. Coco's Italian Market

411 51st Ave N, Nashville, TN 37209

Visitors can load up on fresh burrata, heaps of fettuccine with meatballs, and deep-dish timpano at this restaurant/market hybrid. Post-carb-feast served either indoors or on the covered patio, diners can enjoy a glass of wine or beer while perusing the Italian market.

411 51st Ave N
Nashville, TN 37209

9. Pastaria

8 City Blvd, Nashville, TN 37209
Spencer Pernikoff/Pastaria Nashville

The brainchild of chef Gerard Craft, Pastaria serves up some seriously craveable carbs from its bright and airy outpost in the OneC1ty complex. Watch as dishes like cacio e pepe, garganelli, and pistachio ravioli pile out fresh from the open kitchen. The grab-and-go gelato counter by the door is a nice touch, for a post-pasta sweet treat.

8 City Blvd
Nashville, TN 37209

10. Giovanni Ristorante

909 20th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37212

After 27 years in Manhattan, Giovanni Ristorante found its way to Nashville and firmly planted its flag near Midtown with a snappy bi-level space, and soon followed it up with a counterpart in Belle Meade. Murano glass chandeliers, Venetian plaster, and a Hermes (yes, that Hermes) upholstered bar provide some visual eye candy while plates like pappardelle alla Norcia with black truffles and tagliatelle with veal tempt the taste buds.

909 20th Ave S
Nashville, TN 37212

11. Bella Napoli Pizzeria | Pizza Nashville

1200 Villa Pl #206, Nashville, TN 37212

While Bella Napoli is known for its perfectly blistered pies using ingredients imported directly from Italy, the rest of the menu is worth its weight in pasta gold. Especially when it comes to dishes like rigatoni salsiccia and the pork saltimbocca with Parma prosciutto and fontina cheese. During happy hour, glasses of the house red or white go for $5; well drinks are only $4.

1200 Villa Pl #206
Nashville, TN 37212

12. Caffé Nonna

4427 Murphy Rd, Nashville, TN 37209

Chef Daniel Maggipinto has been charming guests at this Sylvan Park eatery with his grandmother’s (the titular Nonna) traditional recipes for years. Starters like arancini and a hearty Tuscan bean soup segue smoothly into mains like mussels served fra diavolo or apulia-style with a saffron-tomato broth. There’s also a build-your-own pasta plate option featuring rigatoni, gnocchi, and risotto with an abundance of sauces, meats, veggies, and cheeses for topping.

4427 Murphy Rd
Nashville, TN 37209

13. Mangia Nashville

701 Craighead St, Berry Hill, TN 37204

While it’s nice to stop by on a weeknight for a beautifully plated pasta dish by executive chef Nick Pellegrino, Fridays and Saturdays get pretty lit at this Berry Hill Italian spot. One seating is offered from 7 to 10 p.m. and features a family-style meal of various antipasti, pasta dishes, vegetables, and mains like chicken piccata or shrimp scarpiello. Copious glasses of wine turn the atmosphere up a touch and give guests the liquid courage to get up and bust some moves.

701 Craighead St
Berry Hill, TN 37204

Related Maps